Question
QUESTION: I haveter system? comparable quotes for two systems - Raibird (ESP controller, 5000 series rotors, 1800 series sprays) and Hunter (Pro-C controller, PGP rotors and PS sprays). Which is a bet

ANSWER: Neil,

I really appreciate the chance to help you make an educated decision on a new sprinkler system.

The components you mentioned are really a toss up, before I make a recommendation please include the following if possible>

Product count from each proposal:

1. Amount of rotors, sprays, valves

2. weather sensors: rain or ET

3. Backflow device

4. Companies qualifications or associations with any organizations

5. Type of pipe to be used and installation techniques (trenching or plowing along with depth of pipe) for both the main line and lateral lines

6. Warranty from each company

Bob

---------- FOLLOW-UP ----------

QUESTION: First quote:
1. Hunter Pro-C controller, 10 PGP rotors, 17 Hunter Pro Sprays, 5 zones but contractor said this could change after main is put to the meter.2. Optional ireless rain sensor $200  3.Backflow device on dedicated water source and ball valve shut off. 4. Certified Irrigation. 5. Ploughing. 6. 5 yr. warrnty. Price 2800. Poly pipe 3/4 inch
Second - all same but  8Rainbird  rotors 5004, 12 Spray heads 1812, 10 sprays 1804, 8 valves, rain sensor incl, price 2500, poly pipe 3/4 inch

Answer
Neil,

All things being equal, meaning that both companies have a solid reputation and are using identical installation techniques (I would hands down go with a company that does not use "saddles" but instead uses all insert fittings. Saddles are typically white or yellow and they clamp around a pipe. They always cause problems down the road. And that both companies are quoting the same backflow preventor and are abiding by local plumbing codes.

I would opt for the second quote for the following reasons:

1. Your second quote is including (12) 1812's which are 12" spray heads typically used in flowerbeds. 12" heads are the way to go, your first company just quoted pro sprays so you would have to assume that they would all be 4" sprays.

2. No responsible company should charge a new install client money for a rain sensor since they are a proven water saver and inexpensive. Also I know that Hunters wireless rain sensor has had a lot of problems of late and they have been on back order for over two months since they are trying to work out an issue. The Hunter wired Mini-Clik rain sensor is one that has worked well for us over the years.