QuestionQUESTION: I have a leaning pine tree from a storm.
Should I have it cut down or leave it?
Does it have a tap root?
ANSWER: It抯 important to understand that any tree broken, moved, or damaged in anyway by the wind has been compromised. Once compromised a tree could have a high possibility of failure. Some trees can be saved, others must or should be removed.
The first and most important thing is to determine if the damaged tree presents a hazard in anyway. This would be described as a tree, or any part of a tree that could fall on an area where people, structures, cars, equipment, etc. are present or may be present. This would include homes, garages, carports, barns, cars, streets, sidewalks, playgrounds, parking lots, etc. Also, if over head utility lines are present and could be hit if the tree falls. If this is the case, then the tree is considered a hazard and removal may be necessary
A leaning tree may or may not be a problem. Look at the base of the tree for signs of the roots being moved. A tree is leaning with recent root exposure, soil movement, or soil mounding near the base of the tree. A raised mound or changed ground level at base of the tree may indicate the tree has recently begun to lean, and may soon fail. If the lean is more than 20 degrees and the roots have been damaged from the wind storm and the tree will hit a target (house etc) it is a candidate fro removal. Pines do have a tap root that help hold the tree in place.
I would call the local office of the Sate Forestry Agency and ask one of their Foresters to come take a look. This is a free service in most states and they should be able to advise you after seeing the tree.
---------- FOLLOW-UP ----------
QUESTION: Just briefly to add credibility to my effort to save the tree, could you summarize your qualifications as an expert on this subject?
AnswerI retired a couple of years ago with 34 years as the head of the Forest Health section of the Alabama state Forestry Commission. I have a degree in Forest management and Entomology and done extensive work with city trees as well as forest trees here in Alabama. I am Registered Forester here in Alabama.
