Question
My question contains two parts:Is windthrow considered an ACT OF GOD or is it preventable with reasonable management methods? Is the willow leaf oak more likely to be downed by wind than other trees in the forest?                              Thanks
                                    
                                     Brian

Answer
Brian,

This sounds like a question having legal consequences and as such is beyond the scope of this forum.

I have included the definition of windthrow for you.


windthrow, which occurs when the stem and rootplate of a tree overturn (with the rootplate remaining substantially intact). Windthrow is caused by the failure of poorly drained soil beneath the root plates to anchor the tree.

Good luck